From the X archive · November 8, 2026

I Did the Work, Char — An audit of Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa's 1st Timothy sermon

November 8, 2026 · Faith · Scripture

1 Timothy 3:2 — ΜΙΑΣ ΓΥΝΑΙΚΟΣ ΑΝΔΡΑ. The plumb line doesn't move.

"Do your own work"

On Saturday night, November 7, Char Brodersen, lead pastor of Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa, answered my challenge on the Greek of 1 Timothy like this:

"Anyone can use an Ai search engine. What have you proved? Do you want to actually dialogue with me from your own brain what you have studied and where you take a biblical issue with what I said?"

Then: "Do your own work." He said he'd be teaching from 1 Timothy the next morning if I wanted his take. His last word that night: "I honestly have no idea what you just said... Again, do your own work and then we can talk."

Fine, Char. I made a transcript of your November 8 sermon and checked its claims against the Greek text, the rest of Scripture, and the sources you leaned on. Here's the work.

This is what Costa Mesa is defending, read from the pulpit:

"Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa believes and practices the ordination of both men and women to pastoral ministry as a recognition of the priesthood of all believers and the unique gifting of individuals by the Holy Spirit..."

And then:

"...we've actually been practicing these things as a local church for nearly a decade... So we aren't changing anything in our current practice, but we simply wanted to clarify our biblical position and conviction."

Practice first. The public biblical case, a DECADE later.

The sermon is that case, and it doesn't survive contact with the text.

It:

Receipts below.

He called it plain. Then he overruled it.

Char opened by restating his rules for interpretation.

Rule one: We do not use a single verse to create doctrine (paraphrased)

Rule two: "we do not derive doctrine from confusing or interpretively problematic text, but instead we use clear passages to interpret and understand confusing or problematic passages."

Then he read 1 Timothy 2:11–15 and conceded the point:

"Now, the plain meaning of the passage that we are concerned with, which is verses 11 through 15, is that Paul is not allowing women to teach and lead the church in Ephesus."

A few minutes later, on verse 15: "The truth is nobody knows exactly what Paul is talking about here." Fair. Verse 15 is hard. It's the same verse he threw at me on X: "Everyone has a take."

Now watch the move. He explains the hard verse with Artemis lore. Then he uses that explanation to shrink the verse he already called plain down to Ephesus, "at this time." The unclear interprets the clear. That's his rule two, run backward.

Artemis isn't named anywhere in 1 Timothy. Neither is "for now." The only reason in the passage is the one Paul gives in the next verse.

Paul already answered "why"

Char's big question from the pulpit: "I think the question that we need to ask is, why?"

Paul answers it in the next breath. Verse 12 states the restriction. Verse 13 turns on γάρ, "for," "because":

"For Adam was formed first, then Eve. And Adam was not the one deceived; it was the woman who was deceived and became a sinner." (1 Tim 2:13–14, NIV, the translation Char read from)

Paul's reason is Genesis 2 and 3. Not Ephesus. Not Artemis. Not a crisis "at this time."

And Paul runs the same creation-order argument in a different letter to a different city: "For man did not come from woman, but woman from man; neither was man created for woman, but woman for man" (1 Cor 11:8–9). Different church, same argument from Genesis.

The sermon swaps the reason Paul gives for one Paul never gives. That isn't context. That's replacement.

"Why doesn't Paul write this in any of his other letters?"

He did.

"Women should remain silent in the churches. They are not allowed to speak..." (1 Cor 14:34, NIV)

"Not allowed" there is οὐ … ἐπιτρέπεται, from ἐπιτρέπω. That's the same verb as "I do not permit" (οὐκ ἐπιτρέπω) in 1 Timothy 2:12, the wording Char called "unique language." Same verb, same subject, different city. You can argue about what 1 Corinthians 14:34 means. You can't say Paul never wrote anything like it.

The elder qualification isn't Ephesus-only either. Titus 1:5–6 requires elders "in every town" on Crete to be a "one-woman man" (μιᾶς γυναικὸς ἀνήρ). Different island, same requirement.

Char also called 1 Timothy "a personal letter," not "a general epistle to the churches." Paul says what the letter is for: "you will know how people ought to conduct themselves in God's household, which is the church of the living God, the pillar and foundation of the truth" (3:15, NIV). That's church order, not a private memo about one city's crisis. The block that leads into verse 12 opens with "I want the men everywhere to pray" (2:8). "Everywhere" is ἐν παντὶ τόπῳ, "in every place."

His last argument here: if this were Paul's normal practice, Timothy "would already know." By that logic Paul didn't need to tell Timothy that an elder can't be a drunk (3:3). He wrote it down so the church would have it in writing (3:14–15).

Decoding Paul with a novel

Char's Artemis case starts at verse 9: braided hair, gold, pearls, expensive clothes. From the pulpit he claimed:

The first claim is true. πλέγμα (braids) appears only here in the New Testament.

The second is false. Luke records Paul himself using the words for gold and clothing, χρυσίου and ἱματισμοῦ, in his farewell to the Ephesian elders: "I have not coveted anyone's silver or gold or clothing" (Acts 20:33). "Expensive" (πολυτελής) also shows up in Mark 14:3 and 1 Peter 3:4.

Then there's the parallel that sinks the Artemis decoder. Peter gives women the same instruction, braided hair, gold, clothing (ἐμπλοκῆς τριχῶν … χρυσίων … ἱματίων), in a letter to believers across five Roman provinces (1 Pet 1:1; 3:3). Plutarch told Greek brides the same thing: "It is not gold or precious stones or scarlet that makes her such, but whatever invests her with that something which betokens dignity, good behaviour, and modesty" (Advice to Bride and Groom 26). It was a stock moral theme across the ancient world. It needs no Artemis key.

As for the Ephesiaca: it's a romance novel, a love story about a young couple who meet at a festival of Artemis. Classical scholars long dated it to the second or third century AD; some now argue for the mid-first. Either way it's fiction. A festival hairstyle in a novel doesn't tell you the women in Timothy's church were ex-devotees teaching heresy.

The book Char leaned on hardest, Sandra Glahn's Nobody's Mother, has drawn fire from specialists too. Rick Oster, professor emeritus of New Testament who spent a year of postdoctoral research on ancient Ephesus and the Artemis cult, called its localizing move an "'I wish the Bible said that' hermeneutic masquerading as historical research and exegesis."

Wrong man, wrong suspects

Char built his Acts 19 background like this:

"And there's a man, Alexander the Coppersmith, that stirs up the whole city and claims that Paul has come here and basically undermined the whole claim and pride of Ephesus."

That's Demetrius. Acts 19:24 names him: "A silversmith named Demetrius, who made silver shrines of Artemis." He called the craftsmen together and started the riot. The Alexander of Acts 19:33 was a Jew the crowd shouted down. "Alexander the metalworker" (coppersmith in the KJV) is 2 Timothy 4:14. Char is preaching through Acts.

Then the suspects. Char's theory is that women out of the Artemis cult were going house to house "teaching things they ought not to teach." That line is Titus 1:11, word for word in the NIV, and it's about "the circumcision group" on Crete. The women in 1 Timothy 5:13 are idle young widows "saying things they ought not to" (λαλοῦσαι, "talking"). Paul's fix for them is to marry and manage their homes (5:14), not a ban on women teaching men.

The false teachers Paul actually names are men. Char read 1 Timothy 1:1–11 and stopped. Nine verses later: "Among them are Hymenaeus and Alexander, whom I have handed over to Satan to be taught not to blaspheme" (1:20). Second Timothy adds Philetus (2:17). Their error is "myths and endless genealogies" from people who "want to be teachers of the law" (1:4, 7), not Artemis lore.

When men taught error, Paul silenced those men. He never barred men from teaching. When he gets to women in 2:12, the restriction is general, and he grounds it in Adam and Eve.

Char also said 1 Timothy isn't "testy" like Galatians, so Paul couldn't have been correcting a breach of his normal practice. The same first chapter hands two men "over to Satan."

"Authenteō" doesn't mean what he said

On the verb in 2:12 (αὐθεντεῖν, "assume authority" in his NIV), Char told the room: "it's actually a very strong and often violent word. It's not used positively in any Greek literature... it means to be taken against your will to do something." Then: "Often times it's used as referring to a master with his slave."

No source given. Here's what the people who have counted the occurrences report:

Scott Baldwin examined 82 occurrences in ancient literature and papyri. No example means "to murder" until the tenth century AD, and none carries the negative senses in New Testament times.

Al Wolters surveyed every known occurrence in ancient and medieval Greek and concluded the verb is not pejorative. It doesn't mean "domineer."

Andreas Köstenberger, who co-edited the volume those studies appear in, concedes the early data is thin: the verb shows up only once or twice before Paul.

So the word is rare and its meaning is argued. Egalitarian scholars like Philip Payne read "assume authority" negatively. That's a real debate, and "not used positively in any Greek literature" is not a finding from it. Translations run from "exercise authority" (ESV) to "assume authority" (NIV) to "usurp authority" (KJV). None says "force someone against their will."

Now grant Char his meaning anyway. If αὐθεντεῖν meant abusive, coercive control, Paul would forbid it to everyone. He forbids it to women, pairs it with teaching under one "I do not permit," and grounds both in Adam and Eve. Abuse doesn't need a creation-order argument.

"Mutualism" is egalitarianism with a new label

Char: "we don't affirm the idea of egalitarianism because we do not believe that men and women are the same." He calls his view "mutualism."

Evangelical egalitarians don't claim men and women are the same. Read the founding statement of Christians for Biblical Equality, Men, Women and Biblical Equality. Its case rests on gifts: the Holy Spirit "sovereignly distributes gifts without preference as to gender," so women's gifts belong in ministry "at all levels of involvement."

Now reread Costa Mesa's statement: ordination of men and women "as a recognition of the priesthood of all believers and the unique gifting of individuals by the Holy Spirit." And Char from the pulpit: the Spirit's gifts come "without any criteria or discrimination concerning a difference in gifts and giftings for men and women."

Same argument. Same conclusion. Call it 'mutualism' if you like. It's the egalitarian position with a new name on the door. Your semantics cannot hand wave it away!

The chapter he never read

Char told the room there is "one passage in scripture that seems to forbid women from teaching and leading in the church." There are more, and the most direct is the very next chapter.

Paul's qualifications for an overseer, 1 Timothy 3:2: μιᾶς γυναικὸς ἄνδρα, "faithful to his wife" in Char's NIV, literally "a one-woman man." The noun is ἀνήρ: male, husband. Not ἄνθρωπος, the general word for a person. Verses 4–5 add that he must "manage his own family well." Titus 1:6 repeats the qualification for elders on Crete.

And Paul knew how to write the female version. Two chapters later, a widow put on the church's list must be "faithful to her husband" (5:9): ἑνὸς ἀνδρὸς γυνή, "a one-man woman." Same letter, same idiom, flipped. For overseers, he wrote it male.

There's honest debate over what "one-woman man" requires: no polygamy, no remarriage, or plain marital faithfulness. None of those readings changes the sex of ἀνήρ.

Gifts aren't offices, either. Romans 12 and 1 Corinthians 12 list gifts. 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1 list qualifications for an office. The same Paul wrote both. Char's own rule three, "the full witness of scripture," includes 1 Timothy 3:2. His sermon never read it.

You told me to do my own work

Char, you asked where I take a biblical issue with what you said. That's where. None of it is a "take." Every point above is a verse you can open, a Greek word you can look up, or a source you can read.

And yes, I use tools. You used Sandra Glahn and Preston Sprinkle. I used mine. The difference is that everything here is cited, so nobody has to trust me, you, or a machine.

You told me to do my own work. I did. Now answer 1 Timothy 3:2.

"Is not my word like as a fire? saith the LORD; and like a hammer that breaketh the rock in pieces?" (Jeremiah 23:29)

— Matt Gibson

Related: Rev. Dr. Daniel R. Hyde

After I published this audit, Rev. Dr. Daniel R. Hyde — founding pastor of Oceanside United Reformed Church, a son of the Jesus Movement whose father came to Christ through Pastor Chuck — released a full response to Costa Mesa. He does the positive case across the whole canon. Watch it. Read it. Credit him for the work.

Hyde develops ground that locks the same text I audited:

  1. Before the Fall, Adam already held prophetic (naming), priestly (abad / shamar), and kingly tasks as covenant head — and Adam's sin, not Eve's, is the representative act (Romans 5; 1 Corinthians 15). That is why "secondary issue" language fails.
  2. Acts 1:21 requires Judas's replacement to be one of the men (andrōn / anēr). Women were in the room. The office still required a male.
  3. Acts 6: the seven chosen to serve widows were andras, not anthrōpous. If there was ever a moment to appoint women to serve women, that was it. The apostles still chose men.
  4. Gift is not office. Romans 12 and 1 Corinthians 12 list gifts for the body. 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1 list qualifications for an office. Hyde presses the same distinction Costa Mesa collapses under "priesthood of all believers."
  5. Exodus 19 already called Israel a kingdom of priests — and God still set apart Aaron's line. Korah's rebellion (Numbers 16) used the priesthood-of-all argument. Peter can say every believer is a priest and still address elders as a distinct group.
  6. Galatians 3:28 is standing before God, not a sociological eraser of husbands, wives, slaves, and children in the household codes.
  7. On Artemis: Paul never names her in 1 Timothy. He names Hymenaeus and Alexander. He grounds 2:12 in creation order. Hyde points to S. M. Baugh and G. K. Beale against the Nobody's Mother localizing move.

Hyde is nicer about this than I am. He's also thorough. If you're Calvary and feeling burned, he opens Oceanside URC as a refuge. Read him. Watch him. Then come back to 1 Timothy 3:2.

Credit: Rev. Dr. Daniel R. Hyde, Oceanside United Reformed Church. Video and manuscript © Daniel R. Hyde, November 2026. Used here with attribution.

Sources

Sermon: Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa, Sunday service, Nov 8, 2026, on YouTube. Quotes are from its transcript.

Greek: SBL Greek New Testament. English quotations: NIV (2011), the translation read in the sermon.

Plutarch, Advice to Bride and Groom 26, on Perseus

The Ephesiaca's label and disputed date: Gary Hoag interview, Bible and Culture

Rick Oster, review of Nobody's Mother

Christians for Biblical Equality, Men, Women and Biblical Equality

Baldwin's 82 occurrences of αὐθεντέω: Sam Storms

Wolters' survey and Payne's reading: Women in the Church, 3rd ed.

Köstenberger on the thin pre-Pauline data: interview

Daniel R. Hyde, Can Women Be Pastors? A Response to Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa (Nov 2026): https://www.danielrhyde.com/articles/can-women-be-pastors ; video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IcpgzmlD8FA

Read the original on X → ← All articles